feat: grant a new plugin or connector to everyone by default — the admin's job is now removal, not distribution
Nightly Build / build (push) Successful in 7m23s
Nightly Build / build (push) Successful in 7m23s
The grant junctions (plugin_access, mcp_global_access, mcp_catalog_access)
stay deny-by-default internally, but the rows are written for you at two
moments and never again:
— an object is CREATED: PluginManager::update_config (first toggle —
the plugins row's birth), mcp::catalog_upsert, marketplace install,
mcp::global_enable
— a user is CREATED: UserManager::register_user
Who is included is the role attrs.auto_grant flag (default true, so every
role predating the attribute behaves like an adult member). The seeded
Children preset sets it to false, which is the whole reason the attribute
exists. Admins are skipped because they hold everything implicitly. The
role editor now exposes the switch as a checkbox.
New crate module: db::access_defaults (seed_new_object, seed_new_user,
set_grant_by_default). Additive columns: grant_by_default on plugins,
mcp_catalog, mcp_global_servers (INTEGER NOT NULL DEFAULT 1).
On the frontend the Roles page gets a "New extensions" column and
checklist; the user's plugin/connector rosters are unchanged. i18n:
en, fr, it.
Docs: new docs/access.md for the assistant, plus index.md cross-link.
CLAUDE.md updated with a full default-access section.
This commit is contained in:
@@ -77,7 +77,7 @@ Two rules keep the boundary real, and both are enforced by the compiler:
|
||||
- **The core never names a plugin.** A plugin contributes tools through `Plugin::tools(self: Arc<Self>)` — the sibling of `http_router()` — so nothing in the core has to downcast to a concrete type. Naming one would drag every plugin in the tree into the core, including a C build via `plugin-transcribe-whisper-local`.
|
||||
- **The core never learns about the process shell.** There is no in-core restart hook — the former `restart` tool and its `tools::restart::set_restart_handler` seam were removed. The only coupling to the supervisor is now the `run.sh` exit-code protocol (exit `255` ⇒ re-exec the same binary by path), a seam no code currently triggers (kept for a future admin-driven restart). The live expression of this principle is `skald_core::boot`, which emits startup lines each shell renders (`src/boot_format.rs` here).
|
||||
|
||||
**Plugin visibility & per-user config.** The admin surface is `#plugins` (`plugin-catalog.js`), a status board — one card per plugin with an enable toggle + health dot + a Configure button — plus `#plugin-detail?id=<id>` (`plugin-detail.js`), which holds the instance-config form for one plugin (the plugin counterpart of `connector-detail.js`). **Granting is user-side, exactly like a connector grant**: the checkboxes live in the **Plugins** section of `#users/{id}` (`users-page.js`), right below that person's connectors, and the plugin's own page keeps only a read-only roster of who holds it, linking there. The question an admin asks is "what may this person use", and answering it plugin-by-plugin meant opening every plugin in turn; one write path also means the two surfaces cannot disagree. Unlike an MCP grant — which gates a runtime snapshotted at login and so needs a synchronous revoke — a plugin grant is re-read from `plugin_access` on every request that depends on it (sidebar pages, `/plugins/mine`, and each inbound channel message: Telegram checks it per message), so a revoke lands with no push and nothing on the bus. Binding-managed plugins (`Plugin::manages_own_access`, e.g. mobile-connector) are absent from the user-side list and rejected by its writer — a box that controls nothing is worse than no box. There is **no generic per-user plugin page**: a plugin with per-user settings (Telegram's pairing, Honcho's opt-in) hosts them in its own sidebar page via `Plugin::web_pages()`, like mobile-connector. Enable/disable + instance config + access grants are gated by the `plugin.manage` capability (admin-only by construction). Visibility is **opt-in**: a row in `plugin_access(plugin_id, user_id)` grants a user sight of an enabled plugin (`plugin_id` is bare TEXT, never a FK — a `plugins` row exists only after the first toggle). Per-user values are stored in `plugin_user_configs` (**admin-readable system.db — never secrets**) and applied through the `Plugin::update_user_config` hook, whose default just stores the blob via the `PluginUserConfigApi` on `PluginContext.user_config`. Telegram is the reference impl: its pairing page (a `web_pages()` fragment with no backend of its own) reads the `{linked, chat_id}` status blob from `GET /api/plugins/mine` and submits the code through `PUT /api/plugins/{id}/my-config`; the override turns it into a `chat_id → user_id` binding (same write path as the `telegram_pairing` tool). Endpoints: admin `GET/PUT /api/plugins[/{id}]`, `GET /api/plugins/{id}/access` (read-only roster) + **`GET/PUT /api/users/{id}/plugins`** (the grant write path, the twin of `/api/users/{id}/connectors`); user `GET /api/plugins/mine` + `PUT /api/plugins/{id}/my-config`.
|
||||
**Plugin visibility & per-user config.** The admin surface is `#plugins` (`plugin-catalog.js`), a status board — one card per plugin with an enable toggle + health dot + a Configure button — plus `#plugin-detail?id=<id>` (`plugin-detail.js`), which holds the instance-config form for one plugin (the plugin counterpart of `connector-detail.js`). **Granting is user-side, exactly like a connector grant**: the checkboxes live in the **Plugins** section of `#users/{id}` (`users-page.js`), right below that person's connectors, and the plugin's own page keeps only a read-only roster of who holds it, linking there. The question an admin asks is "what may this person use", and answering it plugin-by-plugin meant opening every plugin in turn; one write path also means the two surfaces cannot disagree. Unlike an MCP grant — which gates a runtime snapshotted at login and so needs a synchronous revoke — a plugin grant is re-read from `plugin_access` on every request that depends on it (sidebar pages, `/plugins/mine`, and each inbound channel message: Telegram checks it per message), so a revoke lands with no push and nothing on the bus. Binding-managed plugins (`Plugin::manages_own_access`, e.g. mobile-connector) are absent from the user-side list and rejected by its writer — a box that controls nothing is worse than no box. There is **no generic per-user plugin page**: a plugin with per-user settings (Telegram's pairing, Honcho's opt-in) hosts them in its own sidebar page via `Plugin::web_pages()`, like mobile-connector. Enable/disable + instance config + access grants are gated by the `plugin.manage` capability (admin-only by construction). Visibility is a row in `plugin_access(plugin_id, user_id)`, which grants a user sight of an enabled plugin (`plugin_id` is bare TEXT, never a FK — a `plugins` row exists only after the first toggle); the table is deny-by-default but the rows are **written for you at install time** — see the default-access section below. Per-user values are stored in `plugin_user_configs` (**admin-readable system.db — never secrets**) and applied through the `Plugin::update_user_config` hook, whose default just stores the blob via the `PluginUserConfigApi` on `PluginContext.user_config`. Telegram is the reference impl: its pairing page (a `web_pages()` fragment with no backend of its own) reads the `{linked, chat_id}` status blob from `GET /api/plugins/mine` and submits the code through `PUT /api/plugins/{id}/my-config`; the override turns it into a `chat_id → user_id` binding (same write path as the `telegram_pairing` tool). Endpoints: admin `GET/PUT /api/plugins[/{id}]`, `GET /api/plugins/{id}/access` (read-only roster) + **`GET/PUT /api/users/{id}/plugins`** (the grant write path, the twin of `/api/users/{id}/connectors`); user `GET /api/plugins/mine` + `PUT /api/plugins/{id}/my-config`.
|
||||
|
||||
**Plugin HTTP routes & web pages.** Every plugin's `http_router()` mounts at boot under `/api/plugin/<id>/` — **enabled or not**: two shared gates wrap each router (`require_auth`, then `guard::plugin_enabled_gate`, which re-checks the DB flag per request and answers 404 while disabled), so enable/disable serves/stops routes immediately with no restart, and plugin responses carry `Cache-Control: no-cache`. The router contract: cheap and safe to build pre-start, handlers tolerant of the not-running state (resolve runtime state per request through a shared cell, as mobile-connector does). A plugin may also contribute **frontend pages** via `Plugin::web_pages()` (`PluginPage { page_id, title, icon, entry, admin_only, priority }`): `GET /api/plugins/pages` returns the caller's visible pages (admin: all; others: non-`admin_only` pages of granted, enabled plugins) with `entry_url` resolved, and the sidebar renders them as menu entries routed `#plugin/<plugin_id>/<page_id>`. A single `<plugin-page-host>` (`web/components/plugin-page-host.js`) dynamic-imports the fragment ES module the plugin serves from its own router, registers its default-exported HTMLElement class, and mounts it with the `plugin-id` attribute — the fragment talks to its backend only through `/api/plugin/<id>/…` and runs with full session privileges (plugins are trusted: they ship in the binary). The frontend knows nothing about plugin page contents or behavior.
|
||||
|
||||
@@ -144,7 +144,7 @@ Schema is greenfield (no migrations, §0), but a purely **additive** column land
|
||||
|
||||
`system.db` still gets **both** bucket functions — but no longer because the migration is unstarted. It gets the owner schema because it *is* the owner of **shared** memory (`memory_docs`) plus, for now, the globally-scoped `secrets` (`SecretsStore` is built on the system pool and shared by reference into every `UserContext`; the global runtime's *config* now lives in the registry table `mcp_global_servers`, and per-user connector config in each user's owner `mcp_user_servers`). The global runtime no longer writes `mcp_events` there: notification persistence is an explicit `McpManager::new` argument (`EventLog::{Persist,Discard}`), `Discard` for the ownerless global runtime and `Persist` for each per-user one, because an event belongs to whoever it happened to and its only reader (event triage) is per-user. Every *other* owner table is created there but never written to anymore — the global owner-bound managers that would write them (chat/jobs/etc.) are inert (see "Current state"). Fully dropping `create_owner_tables` from `system.db` is blocked on the §4 scope decision for secrets, not on call-site migration.
|
||||
|
||||
`users` (`crates/skald-core/src/db/users.rs`) holds the directory plus auth material. It lives in the system DB, which the box owner can read, so it must never store anything that derives a user's key. `Credentials` is an enum mirroring the table's `CHECK`: an encrypted user carries a **wrapped DEK** (whose AEAD tag *is* the password verifier — hence no `password_hash`); a cleartext user carries an ordinary verifier, or none. `User` is deliberately not `Serialize` and its `Debug` redacts key material — use `User::summary()` for anything leaving the process. `role_id` references `roles(id)` (the `roles` table is now seeded before `users` in `create_registry_tables`). A nullable `locale` column (additive via `ensure_column`) holds the per-user UI language override; role-driven conventions live in the free-form `roles.attrs` JSON — never new columns per attribute — parsed at a **single point** by the typed `db::roles::RoleAttrs` (`ui_mode`, `permission_groups`, `chat_agent`): `ui_mode` (see the frontend section) plus the role's **security-group set** (`roles.permission_group` = the default group, `attrs.permission_groups` = additional allowed groups; `Role::effective_groups()` = the union, `roles::role_allows_group()` gates it with `admin` short-circuiting to all). See the security-group picker in the frontend section. The role's **default entry (chat) agent** is `attrs.chat_agent` — the neutral `chat`-type agent members of the role land on (§0.1: data, not an enum). Resolved by `roles::default_chat_agent_for_user(registry_pool, user_id)` — the single seam behind both the per-user `ChatHub`'s `default_agent` (snapshotted at login in `UserContextFactory::build`, like fs/MCP access, so **every** session-creation path — explicit `provision_session`, lazy WS `get_or_create_session`, notify — honors it) and `provisioning_for_source`'s non-project branch. Falls back to `agents::DEFAULT_CHAT_AGENT` (`"assistant"`, the renamed former `main`) when unset. Seeded: `admin`/`member` → `assistant`, `children` → `kid` (Companion). A per-user override is future work, layering on top in the same resolver. The stack **root frame** is created with the session's own `agent_id` (not a literal) — `config.agent_id` (from the frame) drives which prompt runs, so a wrong id there silently runs the wrong agent. The admin-managed **directory profile** lives in three more additive columns — `birthdate` (ISO `YYYY-MM-DD`), `sex` (free text), `notes` (admin-authored) — edited only from the Users admin page (`set_directory_fields`; validation — real non-future date, length caps — lives in the `users_mgmt` API, not the db layer) and rendered into agent prompts by the `__USER_PROFILE__` substitution (see above). They are directory metadata written *by* the admin *about* the user, so the registry is their honest home under the §2 threat model.
|
||||
`users` (`crates/skald-core/src/db/users.rs`) holds the directory plus auth material. It lives in the system DB, which the box owner can read, so it must never store anything that derives a user's key. `Credentials` is an enum mirroring the table's `CHECK`: an encrypted user carries a **wrapped DEK** (whose AEAD tag *is* the password verifier — hence no `password_hash`); a cleartext user carries an ordinary verifier, or none. `User` is deliberately not `Serialize` and its `Debug` redacts key material — use `User::summary()` for anything leaving the process. `role_id` references `roles(id)` (the `roles` table is now seeded before `users` in `create_registry_tables`). A nullable `locale` column (additive via `ensure_column`) holds the per-user UI language override; role-driven conventions live in the free-form `roles.attrs` JSON — never new columns per attribute — parsed at a **single point** by the typed `db::roles::RoleAttrs` (`ui_mode`, `permission_groups`, `chat_agent`, `auto_grant` — the last one being why that struct's `Default` is hand-written, see the default-access section): `ui_mode` (see the frontend section) plus the role's **security-group set** (`roles.permission_group` = the default group, `attrs.permission_groups` = additional allowed groups; `Role::effective_groups()` = the union, `roles::role_allows_group()` gates it with `admin` short-circuiting to all). See the security-group picker in the frontend section. The role's **default entry (chat) agent** is `attrs.chat_agent` — the neutral `chat`-type agent members of the role land on (§0.1: data, not an enum). Resolved by `roles::default_chat_agent_for_user(registry_pool, user_id)` — the single seam behind both the per-user `ChatHub`'s `default_agent` (snapshotted at login in `UserContextFactory::build`, like fs/MCP access, so **every** session-creation path — explicit `provision_session`, lazy WS `get_or_create_session`, notify — honors it) and `provisioning_for_source`'s non-project branch. Falls back to `agents::DEFAULT_CHAT_AGENT` (`"assistant"`, the renamed former `main`) when unset. Seeded: `admin`/`member` → `assistant`, `children` → `kid` (Companion). A per-user override is future work, layering on top in the same resolver. The stack **root frame** is created with the session's own `agent_id` (not a literal) — `config.agent_id` (from the frame) drives which prompt runs, so a wrong id there silently runs the wrong agent. The admin-managed **directory profile** lives in three more additive columns — `birthdate` (ISO `YYYY-MM-DD`), `sex` (free text), `notes` (admin-authored) — edited only from the Users admin page (`set_directory_fields`; validation — real non-future date, length caps — lives in the `users_mgmt` API, not the db layer) and rendered into agent prompts by the `__USER_PROFILE__` substitution (see above). They are directory metadata written *by* the admin *about* the user, so the registry is their honest home under the §2 threat model.
|
||||
|
||||
## Filesystem & containers (blueprint §6)
|
||||
|
||||
@@ -217,6 +217,25 @@ For a per-user connector whose credential is produced by **pairing** (`auth.type
|
||||
|
||||
**Deferred:** SSH and other §15 device kinds (would reuse the `login_status` contract), `deliver.as=file`, and non-Google OAuth providers are unimplemented paths that error clearly rather than half-work. No boot seed of catalog presets; the admin populates the catalog from the Marketplace.
|
||||
|
||||
## Default access — the grant tables are deny-by-default, but the rows are written for you
|
||||
|
||||
`plugin_access`, `mcp_global_access` and `mcp_catalog_access` still mean exactly what they meant: **a row is access, its absence is none, every read fails closed**. What changed is who writes the rows. Installing something used to leave it granted to nobody, so the admin then walked the user list; now `db::access_defaults` grants it to the household at the moment of installation and the admin's remaining job is *removal*.
|
||||
|
||||
**The default is materialized, never evaluated.** The tempting alternative — leave the junctions lazy and answer each check as `COALESCE(grant.allowed, object.grant_by_default)` with signed rows for exceptions — needs no seeding but costs two things worth more. The checkbox loses a state (an unticked box would mean either "denied" or "inheriting", indistinguishable to the admin), and "who has what" stops being one query: the gate, the plugin roster and the user checklist all read the same junction today, and `plugin_access.plugin_id` is bare TEXT with no `plugins` row to join a default against. So the default is applied at exactly **two moments** and never again:
|
||||
|
||||
| moment | seam | what fires |
|
||||
| ---- | ---- | ---- |
|
||||
| an object is **created** | `access_defaults::seed_new_object` | `PluginManager::update_config` (first toggle — the `plugins` row's birth), `mcp::global_enable`, `mcp::catalog_upsert`, `marketplace` install |
|
||||
| a user is **created** | `access_defaults::seed_new_user` | `UserManager::register_user` — in the core, so no future user-creation endpoint can forget it |
|
||||
|
||||
**Not on enable/disable**, and that is the load-bearing part: re-enabling a plugin must never resurrect a grant the admin took away, so the trigger is the row's *birth*, not its flag. Every call site therefore checks existence **before** its upsert (`is_new_row` / `is_new_server` / `is_new_entry`) — a re-install or an edit seeds nothing. Seeding is additive-only and idempotent on the PK, which is why every call site is best-effort (a `warn!`, never a failed request): a grant that did not get written is fixable from the user's page, and nothing here can ever widen further than the two moments allow.
|
||||
|
||||
**Who is included is a role attribute, not a role id** (§0.1): `roles.attrs.auto_grant`, parsed by `RoleAttrs` like everything else there. It defaults to **`true`** — hence the hand-written `impl Default for RoleAttrs`, since a derived one would give `false` and silently invert the feature for every role predating the attribute. The seeded `children` preset sets it to `false`, which is the whole reason the attribute exists. `admin` answers `false` too, but as a *skip*, not a denial: admins hold everything implicitly (`plugin_access::effective_access` short-circuits), so rows for them would only be noise in every roster. Editable in the role editor (`roles-page.js`, which persists only the opt-out).
|
||||
|
||||
**Per-object opt-out** is `grant_by_default` on `plugins` / `mcp_global_servers` / `mcp_catalog` (additive via `ensure_column`, default 1). One thing sets it today: a binding-managed plugin (`Plugin::manages_own_access`, mobile-connector) is marked `0` at row creation, because it never reads `plugin_access` and rows for it would make its roster claim an audience that means nothing. There is no UI for the flag yet — `access_defaults::set_grant_by_default` is the seam when one is wanted. Changing it is deliberately **not** retroactive in either direction.
|
||||
|
||||
**A role change does not re-seed.** Promoting a child to an adult role leaves their grants as they were; the admin ticks the boxes once on that person's page. Deliberate: the reverse (demotion) would then have to *revoke*, and a revocation that fires as a side effect of an unrelated edit is exactly the class of surprise the two-moment rule exists to avoid.
|
||||
|
||||
## System agents (event triage, memory lints)
|
||||
|
||||
A **system agent** runs on a user's behalf without being asked. There are three — event triage (the background event processor) and the two memory lints — behind **one** scheduler, and the machinery is deliberately shaped so a fourth is a trait impl plus one line in a registry.
|
||||
|
||||
Reference in New Issue
Block a user